Charlie Wilson has a special place in the US political history. He was a congressman representing part of east Texas, which was characteristic of ultra conservatism and Christian values. However, he was famous for his playboy life style with women, alcohol, and drug use. Yet, it’s not what the movie Charlie Wilson’s War is about.
His main contribution was leading a US covert operation against Soviet Union in its Afghanistan War. With the money, weapon and military training support from the US, Soviets was finally defeated, leading to its collapse a few years later.
Personally I think it’s a very good movie. The director, while on the one hand, praised his effort to curb the spread of communism; on the other hand, is never frugal in revealing the dark corners of US political system, all of which are unfortunately, hopelessly, true. Let’s read through some scripts in the movie:
(FYI, the characters involved are:
Joanne Herring: A wealthy Texas woman, an ultra-right wing, anti-communism, Christian. Wilson’s secret lover and political donor.
Gust Avrakotos: CIA operative, person who carried out Wilson’s initiatives.
Bonnie Bach: Charlie Wilson’s Administrative Assistant)
Section 1:
Joanne Herring: May I ask what it is that I’ve done to make you dislike me, Mr. Avrakotos?
Gust Avrakotos: I like you just fine, Mrs. Herring, it’s just been my experience that when people with money and too much free time get involved in politics, pretty soon, I forget who it is I’m supposed to be shooting at.
Shawshank’s comment:
“Power to the people” is nothing more than a slogan any more. Some ultra right wing political faction in Houston, Texas ended up having changed course of a country (Afghanistan) and the whole world (the collapse of Soviet Union) The “butterfly effect” is scarily amazing.
Section 2:
Charlie Wilson: But I have to tell you, I’m elected by Jews.
Joanne Herring: How many Jews do you have in your district?
Charlie Wilson: Seven. But congressmen aren’t elected by voters, they’re elected by contributors, and mine are in, well, New York, Florida, Hollywood, because I’m one of Israel’s guys on the Hill.
Shawshank’s comment:
The founding fathers of this country painstakingly designed the political system to prevent under represented groups’ voices being ignored, to prevent factions from overwhelming it; yet, they still failed, only 200 years after the system was established.
In essence, campaign donation is just a form of legalized corruption, bribery.
Section 3:
Charlie Wilson: You want me to come to Houston and see a movie?
Joanne Herring: There’ll be women and wealthy donors. See you Friday.
Charlie Wilson: Yes, ma’am.
Shaswhank’s comment:
“Follow the money” It almost becomes the universal law in the world. A sad truth.
Section 4:
Charlie Wilson: You know, I had a neighbor, growing up, with a name right out of Dickens, Mr. Charles Hazard. And Mr. Hazard didn’t like the neighborhood dogs messing up his flower beds. One day, I heard a bunch of yelling from across the street, so I ran on over to Mr. Hazard’s, and there were about 15 grown-ups standing around my dog, Teddy, who was writhing on the ground in obvious agony. Blood was pouring out of his mouth. Mr. Hazard had ground up a glass bottle and put it in a bowl of dog food and fed it to him.
Bonnie Bach: What did you do?
Charlie Wilson: Well, I got some gasoline and burned down his flower beds. But that wasn’t satisfying enough. And then I remembered, Mr. Hazard was an elected official. He was the head of the town council. His reelection every two years was a foregone conclusion. So come Election Day, I drove over to the black section of town. Now, these people hadn’t voted in any of these elections, and I filled up my car with black voters and drove them to the polling place and then waited, then drove them on home. But before they got out of the car to vote I said, “I don’t mean to influence you, but I think you should know Mr. Charles Hazard has intentionally killed my dog.
About 400 ballots were cast in that election. I drove 96 of them to the polls. Hazard lost by 16 votes.
And that’s the day I fell in love with America.
Shawshank’s comment:
In the early days of American democracy, only people with property had the right to vote. The reason behind was only people with their own stake in the country have the real interest in extending the country’s benefits. Later on, as part of the outcome of civil rights movements, suffrage was extended to everyone. Careless voters sometimes become the decisive force in determining the political outcomes.
Final comment: US is supposed to have the best political system in the world, and unfortunately what’s happened in the past week has made it very clear that it is in a dysfunctional state. You might be able to find answers to this situation from Charlie Wilson’s War.